Office of The State Attorney, Fifth Judicial Circuit, Florida
Serving the Citizens of Citrus, Hernando, Lake, Marion, and Sumter Counties
Office of The State Attorney, Fifth Judicial Circuit, Florida
Serving the Citizens of Citrus, Hernando, Lake, Marion, and Sumter Counties

Newsroom

JURY FINDS DWAIN HALL GUILTY ON ALL CHARGES IN THE MURDER OF UNITED KINGDOM WOMAN SONIA EXELBY, SENTENCED TO LIFE

(Marion County, FL) Today, the State Attorney’s Office of the Fifth Judicial Circuit announces a jury has found 54-year-old Dwain Chadwick Hall guilty of Premeditated First-Degree Murder and Kidnapping of Sonia Exelby, a 32-year-old British national from the United Kingdom. Following the verdict, Hall was adjudicated guilty and sentenced by Judge Timothy McCourt to two consecutive Life sentences.

“This was an extraordinary and deeply disturbing case involving circumstances that are difficult to comprehend,” said Bill Gladson, Fifth Judicial Circuit State Attorney. “While no verdict can undo the unimaginable loss Sonia’s family has endured, we hope today’s outcome provides some measure of justice and allows them to begin the long process of healing. Our thoughts remain with Sonia’s loved ones, whose lives have been forever changed. We also hope this case serves as a reminder of the importance of compassion, recognizing vulnerability, and looking out for those around us. Sonia’s life mattered, and she will not be forgotten.”

The case against Hall began on October 13, 2025, when the Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE) Gainesville Field Office received a request for investigative assistance from Interpol regarding a missing and endangered female, identified as Sonia Exelby. Exelby was reported missing from her home in Portsmouth, England. Hampshire & Isle of Wight Constabulary initiated the investigation and discovered that Exelby flew to Gainesville, Florida, just three days prior.

Officials obtained recent credit card transactions for Exelby, which detailed an Airbnb transaction for a rental home in Reddick. FDLE agents responded to the address to conduct a search of the property. While processing the scene, authorities followed up on other transactions on Exelby’s account, which included multiple declined transactions from an auto repair business owned and operated by Hall.

Investigators began looking into Hall and discovered substantial ties to Exelby, despite Hall’s initial denial of knowing the victim. By piecing together cell phone and online records, detectives were able to determine the victim, who suffered from mental health issues, had been communicating with Hall for approximately two years.  After arriving at Gainesville Regional Airport, Hall picked her up and drove the victim to the Airbnb. During their investigation, officials determined that Hall had purchased items, including rope and a shovel, before Exelby’s arrival.

Following an extensive investigation involving the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, the Marion County Sheriff’s Office, and authorities in the United Kingdom, Exelby’s body was discovered buried in a shallow grave in a wooded area of Marion Oaks on October 17, 2025. In the grave, crime scene personnel located a label belonging to a shovel that was later matched to a receipt for a purchase made by Hall, which was captured on a surveillance camera. The shovel was later recovered from Hall’s residence, with examiners finding blood matching Exelby’s on the handle.

An autopsy determined Exelby suffered four sharp-force injuries, and her death was ruled a homicide. Continuing the investigation, law enforcement discovered that Hall had mailed a knife to a friend out of state. The knife was recovered by authorities and later determined to be the murder weapon. Hall was promptly arrested and charged.

This case was successfully prosecuted by Assistant State Attorneys Amy Berndt and Richard Buxman thanks to the diligent work of the Marion County Sheriff’s Office, especially that of Detective Joseph Miller, and the office of FDLE Commissioner Larry Keefe, including lead investigator Rebekah McKinzie.

Published on 11/20/2026.